The Eraser Eye VS Lasting Perfection

The two most popular drugstore concealers on the internet, but why are they so popular? Which one's better? Let's see.

What do they both claim?
Maybelline's 'Eraser Eye' claims to 'instantly conceal dark circles & fine lines.'
Collection's 'Lasting Perfection' claims to 'conceal flaws and blemishes for up to 16 hours.'

I bought The Eraser Eye in the lightest shade, and it's a warm tone, whereas Lasting Perfection is quite pinky toned, which is apter for under eye concealing. 

As you can see, Lasting perfection is a lot lighter that Eraser Eye (and they're both the lightest in the ranges) so it's a more brightening highlighter than eraser eye. But let's see which one works best at tackling my under-eye bags!

Lasting Perfection: It's quite mattifying, so it doesn't highlight your dark circles.
Eraser Eye: It's pretty dewy, which isn't good for under eye coverage. Also the product settle in the fine lines under my eyes, which it claimed to erase.

This is just my opinion, I have to stand by what works for me, and that is Lasting Perfection. Let me know which one works best for you in the comments!

 - Click to subscribe to Simple Enchantment (IT'S FREE!)